Jurisfiction: Law as a Work of Art

When:
Venue: Birkbeck 30 Russell Square, 101
Booking details: Free entry; booking required

Centre for Law and theHumanities Annual Lecture

Jurisfiction: Law as a Work of Art

The Centre for Law and Humanities at the School of Law, Birkbeck is delighted to welcome Professor Jennifer L. Culbert (Krieger School of Arts & Sciences, John Hopkins University).

Justice Brett M. Kavanaugh and Jacques Derrida make strange bedfellows. However, as I show in this talk, both men insist, in Derrida’s words, “We must remain ignorant of who or what or where the law is, we must not know who it is or what it is, where and how it presents itself, whence it comes and whence it speaks” (“Before the Law” 204). As then-Judge Kavanaugh put it in his first set of hearings before the U.S. Senate Judiciary Committee as part of his confirmation process, “legislative history is useful for understanding why something came to be, but not as a tool for upsetting or – or changing your interpretation of the words of the statute.” As a “textualist,” he subscribes to the position that “if we are going to exercise judgment, not will, we need to adhere to the law as passed. And the law as passed is reflected in the written words that were – went through both houses and signed by the president.” He notes, “the legislative history…are not part of the law as passed.”

In this talk, I will argue that law, as demonstrated by both Justice Kavanaugh and Derrida, is a work of art. As a work of art, what guides or binds our conduct or action is a rule, custom, or practice that, for all intents and purposes, appears as if out of nowhere. For the law stands alone, apart from its author(s), at a remove from any origin. It is not the product of reason or even skill but rather, in Plato’s words, “an imitation of a phantasm.” To make this observation is not, in this talk at least, to criticize or condemn the law for being irrational, irrelevant, or poorly made. Rather, it is to start drawing a picture of law as a fabrication or fiction, inspired by Hannah Arendt’s political theory and concept of “work.” It is also to take up playfully but with renewed seriousness critical evaluation of legislation and legal interpretation in terms of aesthetic judgment.

About the Speaker

Jennifer L. Culbert is an associate professor in the Department of Political Science. She received her PhD from the Rhetoric department at UC Berkeley and taught at Arizona State University as well as Amherst College before coming to Johns Hopkins University. At Johns Hopkins University, she teaches courses in political theory and law. She has interests in a wide range of subjects, including state violence, jurisprudence, ethics, judgment, aesthetics, and language. She has written articles and book chapters on revenge, mercy, pain, capital punishment, metaphysics, the philosophy of becoming, and law and literature. She is the author of Dead Certainty: The Death Penalty and the Problem of Judgment (Stanford University Press, 2008) and the co-editor, with Austin Sarat, of States of Violence: War, Capital Punishment, and Letting Die (Cambridge University Press, 2009). She is currently writing a book tentatively called Jurisfiction: Hannah Arendt and Law as a Work of Art. In 2008-2009, she was a fellow at the Murphy Institute in the Center for Ethics and Public Affairs at Tulane University, and in 2011 she was a recipient of the Berlin Prize at the American Academy in Berlin, Germany. In 2018, she was recognized by the Association for the Study of Law, Culture and the Humanities with the James B. White Award for the originality and excellence of her contributions to the field and her commitment to the interdisciplinary study of law, culture and the humanities.

About the Centre For Law and the Humanities

The Centre for Law and the Humanities builds on the Law School’s research strengths in the area of law and the humanities including law and aesthetics; law and literature; law and psychoanalysis; critical legal theory; legal history; law and film; and law, space and architecture.

The Centre facilitates and promotes research in law and the humanities within the School and College through the organisation of seminars, workshops, conferences and visits by distinguished scholars.

This event is free however booking is required via this page.

Latecomers to the event are not guaranteed entry. Please be advised that photographs may be taken at the event. Please note that this booking is through the 3rd party service Eventbrite and by making this booking you are a customer of Eventbrite.

Please contact us if you have any access requirements. More details of accessibility at Birkbeck venues can be found here.

Contact name:

Further details: More information about this event …